by Cudedog » Fri May 04, 2018 10:32 am
Barbie:
I have used Nature's Miracle for many years (decades, even - although it used to be called Nilodor) and it works well, totally eliminating the urine smell.
As for McKenzie and Lola - that is a toughie. I, personally, would not allow them to have any kind of confrontation, if it can possibly be avoided. Allowing "one swat from Lola to set McKenzie straight" might mean that your dog is blinded for life if a cat claw connects with a dog cornea.
This happened to me. I hold myself responsible, and even though my dog has been gone to the Rainbow Bridge for these many years, it grieves me still. It caused my dog excruciating pain (she actually screamed) and she was blinded for the rest of her life.
First and foremost, keep in mind that Lola is acting like a cat (doing what a cat will do), and McKenzie is acting like a dog (doing what a dog will do). To hope they "get along" together at some future time is. . . to hope. To expect more "human-like" behaviors (i.e., "getting along"), or to "punish" for exhibiting behaviors that are normal for their respective species is unreasonable - and might cause other problems as well (i.e., trust issues between you and your pets down the road). Simply put: never punish a cat for acting like a cat, or punish a dog for acting like a dog.
A couple of suggestions:
If Lola prefers to avoid McKenzie, let her. Do not force, or even encourage, interaction. I have never had much luck with the "spray bottle" method of correction (notice I do not say "punishment" here - I only say "correction") because you must always have the thing on your hip, you will always fumble to use it at the exact instant it is needed, your "aim" can be off, and it can leak water anywhere (into your couch cushions, for example).
I would try this. Get a length of light rope (light clothes line rope would be good for this - since McKenzie is fairly small, even a bit of light cording - like drapery cord - would probably do). Get a small training collar for McKenzie, and make sure it fits her correctly (not too large, and not too small) in a backwards "P" on her neck as you look down. This is important. If the collar is put on incorrectly, it will not instantly release when the pressure is released. NOTE: a "training collar" (for those who do not understand their proper use) is sometimes called a "choke collar". It isn't. I have used training collars on my dogs for more than 30 (thirty) years. They work well when used correctly, and are not cruel.
Attach the training collar to, maybe, ten feet or so of of the rope or cord. Tie the other end to your belt loop, or around your waist. Keep it on as you do your chores around the house (this will keep McKenzie close to you), or even as you are sitting on the couch watching TV, or reading a book. (**NEVER leave a training collar on any dog when the dog is unsupervised, or you are away from home, or even when the dog is out of your sight when you are home. Even when the dog is just out in the back yard for a potty run.) A training collar just slips on and off over the head, no buckling or unbuckling needed.
As you are sitting reading a book, or watching TV, and McKenzie suddenly dives after Lola, and hits the end of the lead, she will be. . .stopped. Sometimes abruptly, at least the first time. But you don't have to do or say anything - after this happens once, or maybe twice, McKenzie will self-train not to go after Lola. No yelling, scolding, fumbling with a water bottle, none of that. McKenzie will learn that her actions cause an unpleasant reaction - all on her own.
Same with indoor "accidents". McKenzie cannot wander off to a corner somewhere to take a leak without your noticing - because she is tethered to you. If you see her start to squat in your house as she is moving along beside you, you can give her a quick correction (a light jerk on the lead, with maybe a vocal "No!") and immediately take her outside. Stay outside until she pees, no matter how long it takes. Then offer effusive praise, and maybe a treat from your pocket that you have put there just for this purpose.
But keep her on that lead when you are at home, or crated when you are not. If McKenzie is as smart as she sounds, she will probably "graduate" from the use of the training collar after a short period of time. You can be the judge of that.
I have never trained dogs professionally, but I have worked with my dogs with reputable trainers over the course of many years (obedience work is FUN, and teaches communication - a gestural "language" - that facilitates communication between you and your dog). And, of course, I have trained my own dogs at home.
In the blinding incident I mention above, my cat was loose in the house and my dog was just walking by the cat, unconcerned. My cat reared up, making an unprovoked attack on my dog, swatting her in the face as my dog passed. I witnessed the whole thing, and was totally appalled. This cat had been recently acquired from my father, who could no longer keep her and was going to take her to the pound. I took her home instead. I will always regret it.
What did my dog do to the cat when this happened, you might ask? Nothing. Not a thing. Except scream. What did I do to my cat when this happened? Nothing. Not a thing, besides berating myself for not realizing that a cat might, sometimes, act like a cat. Since I had always had cats loose with my dogs in the house without problem in the past I was just not thinking. Since this cat was new to my household (and not reared with my dogs, as my other cats had been) I felt that I "should have known". The cat has never again (nor ever will be) allowed to interact with any dog.
I hope that this story might prove helpful, and might save someone some grief.
Good luck and best wishes to you and McKenzie, Lola and the kitten.
Thank you.
Anne