Yes, yes, Karen...I have participated in the White Elephant gift exchanges with presents staying wrapped and with presents being unwrapped. I vote the passing/stealing of them staying wrapped. It does make it all the sillier because there is the imagination at work, the attractiveness of the wrapping, the rattle and the weight of the package
. The main rule we always play by is that during any "round" there is no limit to the number of exchanges....the only rule is that you can not choose the "gift" that was just taken from you hands.....there has to be at least one additional "steal' separating your going back for that "prize gift" that you have eyes for! I am not saying that some "gifts" aren't gone after just to hear the whine of loss on the part of another....that would be so mean.....and we are "nice" people
afterall.
Herschel wants Ms Abby to know that he does appreciate her and is looking forward to meeting her. He just has never met a girl so obviously classy before..well there was that Halloween party a few years back but he wants to forget that experience if he can. Maggie and Peaches are practical women. I am not sure that either of them believe in the fancy stuff. One look at Peaches in her "mud bath" and Herschel instantly respected her creativity.
He wants to know how to get away with that. Tell Abby to invited him for a long forest walk and it will be an instant friendship of kindred spirits.